Civil Discourse – Should Parental consent be required for minors 15 and over to receive gender-affirming care?

Image by freepik

Gender-Affirming Care

Gender Affirming Care is a supportive form of healthcare that can include medical, surgical, mental health, and non-medical services for both transgender and nonbinary people. There are a variety of different types of affirming care used at different stages of life: 

  • Social Affirmation adopts gender-affirming hairstyles, clothing, name, gender pronouns, restrooms, etc. It is used at any stage of life and is classified as reversible. 
  • Puberty Blockers use hormones to pause pubertal development. It is used during puberty and OPA classifies it as reversible. 
  • Hormone Therapy uses either Testosterone or Estrogen hormones to cause physical changes associated with someone’s gender. It is used during early adolescence and onward and is classified as partially reversible.
  • Gender-Affirming Surgeries vary widely and are typically used in adulthood or on a case-by-case basis for adolescence. They are not reversible and are typically classified as:
    • “Top” surgery – which creates a male-typical chest shape or enhances breasts.
    • “Bottom” surgery – which changes genitals or reproductive organs.
    • “Facial” surgery & other procedures – surgery to change facial or other features of the body to affirm someone’s associated gender.

Source: US Department of Health and Human Services

Parental Consent

Parental consent laws refer to consent given on a minor’s behalf by at least one parent, or a legal guardian, or by another person properly authorized to act for the minor, for the minor to engage in or submit to a specified activity. Laws of some jurisdictions require parents’ consent to be given for a minor to legally engage in certain activities. For example, parental consent is required before a minor child undergoes medical treatment.
Source: USLegal

Parental consent should be required for minors 15 and over to receive gender-affirming care

Alleyah Forrister, Eagle Hunt, and The Civil Discourse Program

The question of whether gender-affirming care should be available to teenagers 15 and over without parental consent is a complex issue and should be handled with care. Everyone should have access to the care that they need. But if they’re a minor, not without the explicit approval of a parent or legal guardian. 

A person under the age of 18 is a minor, legally. There are little to no exceptions to this in the United States. You have to be a legal adult to vote, adopt a child, and consent to your own medical care. Even less serious things like buying spray paint, working the deli slicer at a grocery store, or getting a Costco card are not allowed until you are 18 years old. These restrictions are put in place for a reason and acknowledge the ongoing developmental maturity of minors. However, we are not talking about buying spray paint or Costco. We are talking about making life-altering decisions without a parent’s consent. Even tattoos, which can be argued as an expression of oneself, require parental consent (the majority of states don’t allow minors to get tattoos at all). Allowing a 15-year-old to get a life-altering medical procedure or treatment without parental consent goes against all of the regulations we have put in place to protect them. 

Think back to when you were 15. Were you 100% confident in who you wanted to be? Do you look back on your younger self and realize everything you did not know? I’m sure many of you do. A close friend of Alleyah’s wanted to get hormonal treatments when she was 15 years old, and if given the chance to do so, she would have. However, her parents did not approve and there was no possibility of treatment without parental consent. This friend resorted to non-medical methods of gender-affirming care, none that would affect her permanently. Checking in with this person at 18 years old – she is now fully confident in herself and her gender identity. She expressed that when she was younger, so many other factors were at play that made her uncomfortable in her own body and made her want to change it. After multiple years of thought and getting to know herself better, she realized that she didn’t truly want to transition, but at 15 years old she didn’t understand what she thought she wanted. Kids these days already have so much pressure from society to look or act a certain way, and it is easy for that pressure to make them want to change themselves. Alleyah certainly remembers what she was like when she was 15 years old; she was not confident in herself or her body. If she had the opportunity to make a change without having to talk to her parents, she’s not sure what she would have done. But if she had made changes then, she knows that she would regret it now.

Allowing minors as young as 15 to get medical procedures or hormonal treatments without parental consent opens the doors to a whole new set of problems. Parents are responsible for keeping their children safe, but cannot do so if they are kept in the dark about their child’s medical history. If a teenager seeks out treatments without knowing their full medical history, they could create potential medical issues for themself in the future. The parent, unaware of their teen’s medical background, would face challenges in the event of an emergency when full knowledge of their teen’s medical history is imperative. Most teenagers don’t have the foresight to consider all aspects of these treatments. Without their parent’s supervision, they could be easily manipulated into expensive treatments that they don’t need. 

Finally, we do not know the full effects of puberty blockers and hormonal treatments on minors. There simply hasn’t been enough evidence collected to figure out the long-term side effects of these drugs. In the United States, puberty blockers and sex hormones do not have U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval for children’s gender care. Oregon Health & Science University states that “Researchers have not finished studying how safe puberty blockers are in the long term. So, there might be some risks that doctors do not yet know about.” OHSU also discloses that puberty blockers can make bones weaker and might make some individuals feel more depressed. They add that hormone treatments can affect one’s ability to have a baby in the future. The National Institutes Health of Health told Reuters in 2022 that “the evidence is limited on whether these treatments pose short- or long-term health risks for transgender and other gender-diverse adolescents.” Additionally, the World Health Organization recently introduced health guidelines for transgender individuals that only cover adults because “the evidence base for children and adolescents is limited and variable regarding the longer-term outcomes of gender-affirming care for children and adolescents.” To be clear, these notable agencies, full of well-qualified medical experts, have not made up their minds on the risks and outcomes teenagers face when taking puberty blockers and hormone therapy. Thus, it only makes sense to conclude that teenagers are also not capable of weighing the costs and benefits of taking these powerful pharmaceutical drugs.

This op-ed is not an argument on whether gender-affirming care should be available to those who need it, but whether minors should be allowed to obtain it without parental consent. Parents and legal guardians are responsible for the well-being of teens under their care until those individuals turn 18. They need to know their teen’s medical condition, what gender-affirming care treatments are being recommended by doctors, and the power to approve or disapprove of any high-risk medical interventions.

Parental consent should not be required for minors 15 and over to receive gender-affirming care

Cheyanne Rider, Zion Okano, and The Civil Discourse Program

Puberty is a scary and confusing time for everyone. Imagine how traumatic it would be to go through puberty in the wrong body. This is the reality for trans youth whose parents deny them gender-affirming care. The age of consent for most medical procedures in Oregon is 15. We believe this is the appropriate age for trans youth to receive gender-affirming care regardless of the guardians’ wishes. Parents are not medical professionals and may not be accepting of their child’s gender identity. There are also many misconceptions about what gender-affirming care entails.

Most parents are not medical professionals and often lack the understanding and credentials to decide what is the best way to care for their child. Of course, this doesn’t mean that a parent should have no say in the matter; they should be able to have multiple doctors and psychiatrists consult their child if they want. However, if the majority of doctors agree something is the best option, there is no reason for the parent to be able to refuse. When parents refuse to follow the medical advice of multiple medical experts, it allows dangerous consequences to occur. Consider the case of Christina Gale Dixon, a parent who put her child’s life in great danger by removing her from chemotherapy and instead treated her daughter’s cancer with oils and vitamins. This is reckless behavior. No parent should be allowed to interfere with evidence-based practices that are recommended by a consensus of doctors to treat a serious medical condition.

Many parents are unsupportive or completely against gender-affirming care in its entirety. In cases like these, it could be obvious that their child is transgender but due to some personal reason, the parents would be unwilling to consider allowing their child to receive gender-affirming care. This can lead to extremely negative outcomes. Zion knew a trans woman whose parents did not allow her to receive gender-affirming care until she was 18. This gave her such mental distress that she was unable to make friends and failed so many classes that she had to retake a year of high school. Now, she has been out as a woman for three years, has a large friend group, and gets straight A’s at college while working a part-time job. Unfortunately, she still suffers from dysphoria and trauma and wishes she could have transitioned earlier.

It is important to understand the various forms of gender-affirming care and the order they are typically administered. Gender identity exploration and working with a behavioral health provider usually occur before puberty blockers and hormone therapy are prescribed. According to Columbia University’s Department of Psychiatry, “Social interventions are considered reversible (meaning that if gender identity shifts in the future, these decisions can be adapted). For example, children may first begin to use a new name or pronoun. Social transition may also involve the use of different clothing or engagement in new activities, such as transferring to a new camp or sports league, that are more congruent with the child’s gender.” A gender therapist “is a licensed mental health therapist [who helps] clients explore and process their gender identity.”  One of the biggest benefits of working with a therapist is that they can help a questioning individual make a distinction between whether they are experiencing gender dysphoria or body dysmorphia. This is an important distinction to make and will help determine subsequent interventions.

If the outcomes of these interventions are positive, then the individual might begin taking puberty blockers. Puberty blockers, which have no known permanent negative effects and are widely seen as completely reversible when taken with proper vitamin supplements, are often taken before gender-affirming hormone therapy (GAHT) starts. If a minor remains on puberty blockers consistently for a significant period of time, there is no reason to doubt that they are transgender and should then take the relevant sex hormone. A 2022 study showed that transgender individuals who begin GAHT during adolescence are less likely to experience depression, suicidal thoughts, and attempts at ending their lives.  Physically developing one’s body in a way that is congruent with their gender identity can have an incredibly positive effect on their mental health.  As Dylan Brandt, a 17-year-old transgender minor, puts it, “My outside finally matches the way I feel on the inside. I have my days, but for the most part, this has changed my life for the better. I can look in the mirror and be okay with the way I look, and it feels pretty great.” Surgery is rare for minors. According to a recent study, fewer than 8% of gender-affirming surgeries in the United States were done on minors. The vast majority of transgender individuals who undergo surgery do so as adults after the previous treatments have been administered.

Medical care is an extraordinarily personal and crucial part of a healthy life. Autonomy is a human right. Everyone deserves to be treated in a way that is best for them, not their parents. 

Scroll to Top